John’s Pizzeria in Times Square has the kind of backstory that people share over a meal. It began with Madeline Castellotti, who walked past an abandoned church on West 44th Street and knew she had found a gem. The place was worn down, but the stained glass ceiling was completely unique. Each section looked like a slice, and that small detail nudged her toward an idea. She spent years turning that old church into a local gathering spot filled with coal-fired ovens, long tables, and the kind of energy that pulls people in.
Now the restaurant feels like part of the neighborhood. You step inside and hear the ovens, the chatter, and the steady movement of a place that has seen every kind of group walk through its doors. The menu keeps people coming back with fresh pies, pasta, and plates that work for just about any crowd.
NYC Slices & Good Times in Times Square
John’s sits at 260 West 44th Street in the center of Times Square, and the space holds close to four hundred guests. It works well for school groups, corporate gatherings, family events, and full restaurant takeovers.
Reservations and event options:
- Reservations available for groups of 15 or more.
- Parties above 25 guests choose from set party packages.
- Full buyouts available for events up to 400 people.
- A menu with coal-fired pizzas, salads, pasta dishes, and options for gluten-free and vegan guests.
- A main floor that is accessible and easy for large groups to move through.
Special packages and partnerships:
- One hour of unlimited pizza plus admission to RISENY for groups of 20 or more.
- Unlimited pizza paired with entry to Madame Tussauds for school groups and celebrations.
- A Comedy Village offer that gives guests 15% off their check with a same-day ticket.
- Comedy Village bundle available for groups of 15 or more, including a reservation at John’s and discounted show tickets.
John’s remains a Times Square staple and is a dependable choice for NYC event planners who want a trusted spot with great food and plenty of room.
Want to explore more spots like this for your clients? Join us at The Event Planner Expo 2026 and meet the teams shaping the city’s event scene.
